About This Site
Books and Stuff
> Favorite Authors
The Gingham Dog and the Calico Cat
Some Reflect, While Others Wonder
What Is Necessary?
An Alien World
Boats and Boxes
The Doctrine of AhimsaAs soon as I mentioned ahimsa in the essay In Other Contexts, I remembered that it had made an appearance in Lord of Light; in fact I remembered exactly where in the story it was, and flipped right to it. I don't know how accurate the explanation of ahimsa is, but the story is fun, and has some nice sophistry.
As he spoke, the beggar brushed from the table before him a red, crawling beetle, the size of a thumbnail, and he moved his sandal as if to crush it.
Actually, I decided to be thorough for once, and looked up ahimsa in Light on Yoga. The comment about insects makes sense within the story, but as far as I can tell, it's not valid. For example,
The yogi believes that every creature has as much right to live as he has.
However, the point about intention is valid, at least in one direction.
But merely because a man is a vegetarian, it does not necessarily follow that he is non-violent by temperament or that he is a yogi, though a vegetarian diet is a necessity for the practice of yoga. Blood-thirsty tyrants may be vegetarians, but violence is a state of mind, not of diet. It resides in a man's mind and not in the instrument he holds in his hand. One can use a knife to pare fruit or to stab an enemy. The fault is not in the instrument, but in the user.
That has to remind you that “guns don't kill people, people kill people”.
In Other Contexts
@ September (2004)